Renting vs Buying a Furnace: Which Option is Best for You?
A furnace is a categorical part of every Canadian home, especially during the long, cold winters. If you’re in the market for a new furnace, you might be wondering whether to rent or buy.
While both options come with their own set of pros and cons, the right choice depends on your financial situation, long-term goals, and personal preferences.
In this blog, we will break down the key differences between renting and buying a furnace to help you make an informed decision.
Renting vs. Buying a Furnace
Renting a furnace offers low upfront costs, predictable monthly payments, and maintenance included in your contract. However, it can be more expensive in the long run due to ongoing rental fees.
On the other hand, buying a furnace requires a higher initial investment but provides long-term savings, ownership benefits, and increased home value.
The final decision ultimately depends on your budget and how long you plan to stay in your home.
Renting a Furnace: Pros & Cons
Renting a furnace is an increasingly popular option for homeowners who want to avoid upfront costs or deal with maintenance themselves. Here are some of its advantages and disadvantages:
Renting a Furnace: Pros & Cons
Pros of Renting a Furnace
- No Upfront Costs: Renting eliminates the need for a large initial investment. You simply pay monthly fees after installation.
- Maintenance Included: Most rental agreements cover maintenance and repairs at no extra cost, giving you peace of mind.
- 24/7 Emergency Service: Rental companies often provide round-the-clock support for breakdowns, even during holidays or extreme weather conditions.
- Flexibility to Upgrade: Many rental contracts allow you to upgrade to newer models easily without additional costs.
- Predictable Monthly Payments: Renting provides fixed monthly costs, making it easier to budget.
Cons of Renting a Furnace
- Higher Long-Term Costs: Over time, rental payments can exceed the cost of purchasing a furnace outright.
- Contractual Obligations: Rental agreements often last 10–15 years, and breaking them early can result in penalties.
- No Ownership: At the end of the contract, you don’t own the furnace and may have to pay additional fees to keep it.
- Limited Service Provider Options: You’re tied to the rental company for maintenance and repairs, which may not always meet your expectations.
Example Scenario:
If you rent a furnace for $150/month over 12 years, you’ll pay $21,600 in total, which is significantly more than buying one outright for $5,000–$7,000.
Transitioning from renting, let’s explore the benefits and drawbacks of buying a furnace outright.
According to Natural Resources Canada, upgrading to an energy-efficient furnace can save homeowners up to 20% on heating bills annually.
Buying a Furnace: Pros & Cons
Buying a furnace requires a larger upfront investment but offers long-term financial benefits and complete ownership.
Pros of Buying a Furnace
- Long-Term Savings: While the initial cost is higher, owning a furnace is more cost-effective in the long run.
- Increased Home Value: A purchased furnace adds resale value to your home since buyers see it as an asset.
- Rebates and Incentives: In Canada, homeowners can take advantage of government rebates like the Canada Greener Homes Grant, which offers up to $5,000 for energy-efficient upgrades.
- Ownership Flexibility: You can choose your preferred service provider for maintenance and repairs.
- No Monthly Payments: Once purchased, there are no recurring fees other than occasional repair costs.
Cons of Buying a Furnace
- High Upfront Costs: Furnaces typically cost $5,000–$7,000 or more, including installation.
- Repair Responsibilities: As the owner, you’re responsible for all repair costs unless you purchase an extended warranty or protection plan.
- Potential for Unexpected Expenses: Repairs can be expensive if your furnace breaks down unexpectedly.
Key Differences Between Renting and Buying
Here’s a quick comparison table to help you weigh your options:
Key Differences Between Renting and Buying
|
Feature |
Renting |
Buying |
|
Upfront Cost |
Low (typically $0) |
High ($5,000–$7,000) |
|
Long-Term Cost |
Higher (monthly payments add up) |
Lower (one-time payment) |
|
Maintenance & Repairs |
Included in monthly fee |
Owner’s responsibility |
|
Ownership |
No |
Yes |
|
Flexibility |
Limited (bound by contract) |
Full control |
|
Resale Value |
None |
Adds value to property |
Long-Term Costs and Flexibility
Now that you know the major difference between renting and buying a furnace, it's time to transition into how each option impacts long-term costs and flexibility.
Renting:
- Rental agreements often span 10–15 years at fixed monthly rates.
- Over time, rental payments can far exceed the cost of purchasing outright.
- Limited flexibility due to contractual obligations; breaking a contract early may incur penalties.
Buying:
- While upfront costs are high, owning a furnace saves money over time.
- You have full flexibility to sell or upgrade your system whenever needed.
- Rebates like Enbridge Home Efficiency Rebate offer up to $3,100 for installing energy-efficient systems in Ontario.
Maintenance and Repairs
One major consideration when deciding between renting and buying is who handles maintenance and repair responsibilities:
Renting:
- Maintenance is included in your monthly payment.
- The rental company covers emergency repairs at no additional cost.
- However, you’re dependent on their schedule for service calls.
Buying:
- As the owner, you’re responsible for all maintenance and repair costs unless covered by a warranty or protection plan.
- You have the freedom to choose your preferred HVAC service provider.
- Investing in annual tune-ups can extend your furnace’s lifespan significantly.
Resale Value and Home Equity
Your decision can also impact your home’s resale value:
- A purchased furnace adds equity to your home since it’s considered an asset by potential buyers.
- A rented furnace may deter buyers who don’t want to assume ongoing rental payments or contracts.
In Ontario’s competitive housing market, homes with energy-efficient furnaces tend to sell faster due to lower operating costs—a key selling point for eco-conscious buyers.
Final Takeaway
When deciding between renting or buying a furnace, there’s no one-size-fits-all answer. It all depends on your financial situation, long-term goals, and personal preferences.
If you value low upfront costs and hassle-free maintenance, renting might be the right choice for you. However, if you’re looking for long-term savings and complete ownership control, buying is likely the better option.
Still unsure? Contact Ascano HVAC today! Our team of experts can guide you through both options based on your needs and budget while offering top-notch installation services. Make an informed decision with Ascano HVAC — your trusted partner in home heating solutions!
FAQs
Is renting a furnace cheaper than buying?
Renting is cheaper upfront because there are no large initial costs, and you only pay a fixed monthly fee that often includes maintenance and repairs. This makes it a convenient option for homeowners who want predictable expenses or don’t have the budget for an upfront purchase. However, over time, rental payments can exceed the cost of buying a furnace outright. For long-term homeowners, buying is usually more economical as it provides ownership and long-term savings.
Are there any tax benefits or rebates when buying a furnace?
Yes! Canadian homeowners can access government rebates like the Canada Greener Homes Grant, which offers up to $5,000 for energy-efficient upgrades. Additionally, some provinces have their own rebate programs, such as the Enbridge Home Efficiency Rebate in Ontario, which provides up to $3,100 for high-efficiency systems. These incentives significantly reduce upfront costs and make purchasing a furnace more affordable. Always check eligibility requirements and apply promptly after installation.
Can I switch providers if I’m renting my furnace?
No, rental agreements typically lock you into one provider for maintenance and repairs throughout the contract term. This means you cannot switch to another service provider without breaking the contract, which often incurs hefty penalties or buyout fees. This lack of flexibility is one of the main drawbacks of renting compared to owning a furnace, where you have full control over service providers.
How long does it take for buying a furnace to pay off?
Buying a furnace usually pays off within 5–7 years compared to renting. After this period, you save money since there are no recurring monthly payments—only occasional maintenance costs. Additionally, owning your furnace increases your home’s resale value and allows you to benefit from energy savings if you invest in an energy-efficient model. This makes buying a cost-effective choice for long-term homeowners.
You Have HVAC Issues, We Have Solutions!
Send us a message
Have a question, feedback, or just want to say hello? We'd love to hear from you! Drop us a message using
Mailing address
Business Hours
Monday - Friday
7:00 AM - 9:00 PM
